ARM Industry Merger and Acquisition Trends

June 14th, 2017

Just two years ago, Kaulkin Ginsberg stated that mergers and acquisitions was the major topic of discussion in boardrooms across the country for the accounts receivable management (“ARM”) industry. In fact, we went as far to declare that the ARM industry was on the verge of rapid consolidation due to the increased costs associated with compliance, changes in client demands, reductions in account placements, and volatile economic conditions. We believed these factors, among others, would cause more owners to sell or merge their businesses in order to remain profitable. As it turns out, we were right that consolidation among ARM companies is taking place. However, we were wrong about the pace of consolidation. As you can see in the chart below, the number of ARM industry firms has been declining more gradually and consistent than we expected, and the aforementioned factors appear to have had very little impact on industry consolidation.

Today, while owners and executives are still discussing strategic acquisition-based growth endeavors, boardroom conversations are more focused on organic growth opportunities with existing and prospective clients – it’s as though a heavy feeling of pessimism has been lifted away from the industry. Additionally, many of the owners we’ve met or worked with in the past appear more willing than ever to make essential capital investments in their businesses to remain competitive as stand-alone entities.

So what gives? Traditional business and economic theory suggests that as costs for an industry increase, so too should the rate of consolidation among remaining companies in order to achieve economies of scale, if revenue more or less remains constant. As you can see in the chart above, revenue for the ARM industry remained relatively flat from 2007 – 2014.

After careful review of the data and numerous discussions with ARM industry veterans, we believe two key factors prevented the ARM industry from abiding by the traditional rules of business and economic theory:

  • First, credit grantors (e.g., hospitals and banks) embrace a third-party common agency theory model. Essentially, under this model credit grantors must preserve a competitive balance in the collection agencies they use to ensure optimal performance outcomes. Without a diverse group of collection agencies, borrowers would begin to associate specific agencies with the credit grantor that might lead to lower satisfaction or usage, which would force less stringent collection actions.
  • Second, and far less analytical in nature, these theories fail to take into account an individual’s desire to continue running a business, even in the face of poor operating conditions. While some businesses took a major hit to their profitability, their owners may have refused to sell their businesses under the current market conditions. Simply put, regardless of value justifications, if an owner couldn’t get enough money for his or her business, then he or she wouldn’t sell the business as long as it wasn’t hemorrhaging money. With nearly 80% of ARM companies being small businesses with fewer than 20 employees, the high level of resiliency among this group seems all the more plausible.

We are happy to report that the U.S. ARM industry withstood the greatest global financial disaster seen by the modern world, and is now poised for even greater levels of growth over the next five years.

For more information about mergers and acquisitions in the ARM industry, including pricing trends, or to learn how your company can access timely ARM research to help you make decisions about growth, please register for KG Prime.

One Response

  1. Joseph says:

    This is an excellent article, very well written. I perked up when I saw "traditional business and economic theory," as this is a subject of considerable interest for me. More particularly, I’m interested in how business and economic theory will be forced to undergo a metamorphosis by the rise of the blockchain.

    The author clearly articulates the divergence of the actual ARM industry from the extrapolated conclusions drawn from traditional theory. However, I’m less interested in the empirical data and more interested to know what you (my reader) think if I change a variable. The revenue does not remain constant. Instead, ARM industries begin implementing blockchain technologies. Here I leave the question open ended. How do you think the introduction of blockchain technologies will alter the trends you’re seeing in the ARM industry in the next few years?

    Sincerely,

    Joseph

Leave a Reply

LATEST BLOGS

Suggestions for my High School Graduate

June 20, 2017

High school graduation is a time of excitement for many as they head off to college. Today, I thought I'd share some of the advice I gave my youngest son in case anyone else has a child preparing to go off to school sometime soon. ....

» see this post    » all posts


ARM Industry Merger and Acquisition Trends

June 14, 2017

Do M&A trends within the ARM industry defy traditional business and economic theories? Today's KG Prime sponsored blog examines industry performance from 2007-present, and the effect changes in operating conditions had on consolidation trends. ....

» see this post    » all posts


The Department of Education Contract: A Candid Discussion between Industry Experts Mike Ginsberg and Randy Kamm

June 13, 2017

The Department of Education unrestricted debt collection contract procurement process seemingly has no end in sight. Industry experts Mike Ginsberg and Randy Kamm examine the current situation, and the decisions that brought us to where we are today. ....

» see this post    » all posts


RECENT ANNOUNCEMENTS

Kaulkin Ginsberg Moves Its Market Intelligence Online

June 8, 2017

Kaulkin Ginsberg is changing the way busy owners, executives, and senior leaders access strategic market intelligence with the launch of KG Prime. KG Prime is a comprehensive and easy to use web-based service that provides users with economic, market segment, and other forms of strategic research.....

» see more




AXIAL FORUM - Publishes "Succession Planning - A Critical Missing Element in Many Family-Owned Businesses"

June 7, 2017

AXIAL FORUM, a web-based strategic mediator for the M&A industry, recently published an article succession planning by Topline Valuation Group. This article was co-authored by members of the Topline Valuation Group and Kaulkin Ginsberg team....

» see more




ACA of Texas Publishes "Three Critical Healthcare Industry Trends for Outsourced Business Services" in its Winter 2017 Magazine

March 16, 2017

The ACA of Texas Publishes "Three Critical Healthcare Industry Trends for Outsourced Business Services" by Kaulkin Ginsberg in its Winter 2017 Magazine. Kaulkin Ginsberg details its belief that the growth in patient lending and financing programs, clinical integration networks, and physician quality reporting systems for the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) could have profound effects on companies focused on servicing healthcare providers in 2017 and beyond.....

» see more