View From The Other Side: Creditor Criteria For Selecting An Agency

December 1st, 2005

From the creditor perspective, "one size fits all" does not apply to the agency selection process. At the end of the day it is all about net back, but the fee is only part of that equation: fitting the agency to the business is a larger consideration. For creditors, the most important factor in selecting agencies is finding ones that fit their needs and want their business.

The first step for creditors is to define their requirements of an agency. To anticipate the questions that prospective clients may ask, it’s good to know the standards against which you’re likely to be measured. Here is a sampling of some of the criteria that creditors use internally to define expectations:

Where should the agency be licensed – in all states, cities, and territories that require it; or is licensing in only specific regions necessary?

What insurance coverage is required? What are the types and dollar amounts of insurance coverage?

Should the agency and/or collectors have a certain number of years in the business, or experience working certain types or levels of placements?

Is agency size a determining factor? Is a 1,000 person agency with 15 branches required, or is one regional agency with 10 collectors a better fit? Do we want to be the largest client at the agency or are we comfortable being the smallest?

Geographic Coverage
What coverage area is needed based on account demographics?

ACA or other industry membership affiliations
Will membership be a requirement for awarding placements?

Security Requirements/Certifications
What data and physical security processes and procedures does the agency have in place? Have they been reviewed or certified by an independent third party? Is this a requirement for them in order to receive placements?

Audited Financials
What proof of financial stability is required? Will only audited financials be accepted?

Off Shore/Near Shore Capabilities
Is there a preference or requirement for off-shore/near-shore operations? Is there a prohibition on accounts being worked off shore?

Other Clients/ Client mix
Are the other clients the agency does business with important? Is the amount and percentage of the agency’s total business from those clients critical?

What reporting will be required from the agency? Are the internal measures the agency uses important?

Client Access, Debtor Access, Online Payments – are any or all of these features on the agency’s website? Is this important?

What capabilities or resources for legal or pre-legal processing are necessary?

Credit Bureau Reporting
Should the agency be required to report to the credit bureaus?

Type of debt to be serviced
Primary, Secondary, Tertiary, Quad, Pre Collect, Early Out, Special Projects, Small Balance, Probate, Bankruptcies, Warehouse: what type and level of business is the placement? Are there specialty types that are needed to assess the agency’s capabilities?

Work Flow Design
How does the agency develop workflows? Do they use scoring models? Do they document client specific workflows?

Collector experience
Is information regarding average tenure at the agency and industry experience important?

Collector turnover
Is turnover rate at the agency important?

Is the content, length, and frequency of collector training important?

Management experience
What is the experience level of the agency’s management/time with the agency, etc.?

Senior management involvement with your account
Is the involvement of senior management / executives / owners important?

Branch operations
Is the existence of branch operations an important consideration? What about whether our business will be worked there?

Technology and Vendor relationships
Is it necessary to know what vendors the agency uses for letter processing, skiptracing, etc? Is the collection software, dialers, telephony they use part of the decision process? Is specific technology required?

Regional vs. national mix
Is most of the agency’s business in one geographic area or is it distributed nationally?

Quality Control/Quality Assurance/Compliance/Compliant Handling
Is a review of procedures in these areas part of the selection process? Are there minimum requirements? Is a list of complaints or lawsuits received in a defined period required?

Once selection criteria have been defined, ranking those items as to importance should be the next step in the agency selection process. There are also some internal considerations for creditors in designing the selection process:

Request For Proposal
Is a formal RFP process going to be required?

Site Visits/Presentations/Interviews
Will there be a site visit prior to selection decision? Will there be phone interviews or presentations required?

Will the fees be dictated or will a bid process be used?

Contract requirements
Are certain work standards a part of the contractual agreement? What are they? Is a separate trust account required? What other contractual requirements are there?

Are references required? How many? How many should be required from clients with similar businesses?

After creditors have defined expectations and have begun the selection process, a more subjective evaluation is necessary to determine how well the agencies demonstrate that they want the business and are willing and able to commit the necessary resources on a timeline that fits the creditor’s needs.

A number of large credit grantors do have formal vendor approval processes in place. Some focus primarily on financial and compliance requirements; others are broader in scope. In any case, whether a credit grantor or debt buyer has a formal selection process or not, it may be worthwhile to craft your proposal using some of these criteria to demonstrate the full value your agency would bring to their network.

For more information, contact us at 301-907-0840 or by email.

Comments are closed.


New York State Now Offers Free College Tuition: The Potential Beginning of a Major Nationwide Trend

April 27, 2017

The Department of Education contract for debt collection services is one of the most lucrative and sought after contracts today by ARM companies. However, state-level legislation like The Excelsior Scholarship could have profound effects on the student loan market.....

» see this post    » all posts

Non-Employment Index: An Alternative Employment Stat

April 26, 2017

The U.S. unemployment rate is a popular measure for looking at the health of the U.S. economy, but alternative measures like the non-employment index may provide even greater insight. In this blog, Kaulkin Ginsberg's analysts examine the strength of the U.S. economy using this alternative measure and its relation to the ARM industry.....

» see this post    » all posts

Healthcare: The Ever-Growing Industry

April 25, 2017

The healthcare industry is one of the most widely analyzed industries in the US due to its seemingly never ending growth. As such, it's no surprise the ARM industry is so focused on the potential impact of a repeal and replace bill for the ACA. ....

» see this post    » all posts


ACA of Texas Publishes "Three Critical Healthcare Industry Trends for Outsourced Business Services" in its Winter 2017 Magazine

March 16, 2017

The ACA of Texas Publishes "Three Critical Healthcare Industry Trends for Outsourced Business Services" by Kaulkin Ginsberg in its Winter 2017 Magazine. Kaulkin Ginsberg details its belief that the growth in patient lending and financing programs, clinical integration networks, and physician quality reporting systems for the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) could have profound effects on companies focused on servicing healthcare providers in 2017 and beyond.....

» see more

ACA of Texas Publishes "M&A Trends in the U.S. ARM Industry" in its Winter 2017 Magazine

March 15, 2017

The ACA of Texas Publishe "M&A Trends in the U.S. ARM Industry" an article by Kaulkin Ginsberg in its Winter 2017 Magazine. This article examines the key trends and developments driving M&A activity in the U.S. ARM industry by market segment.....

» see more

Mike Ginsberg Leading Panel Discussion at DBA International 20th Anniversary Conference

February 1, 2017

Mike Ginsberg, President and CEO of Kaulkin Ginsberg, will be speaking in a panel discussion on Trends in Debt Buying on Wednesday, February 8th at the DBA International 20th Anniversary Conference in Las Vegas, Nevada....

» see more